Framed or Forgotten? Karen Read’s Defense Rests After Explosive Testimony Points to Cover-Up

Dedham, MA – June 12, 2025 -

Karen Read’s legal team officially rested its case this week in a trial that has captivated Massachusetts and raised deep questions about law enforcement integrity. Accused of second-degree murder in the 2022 death of her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, Read’s defense has presented a case built on expert analysis, alleged police misconduct, and growing public concern over what supporters are calling a cover-up.

Two expert witnesses delivered the strongest blows to the prosecution’s narrative. Dr. Andrew Rentschler, a crash reconstruction specialist, testified that O’Keefe’s injuries did not match being struck by Read’s SUV. Instead, he described a scene inconsistent with a vehicle collision, despite the state hinging its theory on exactly that. Dr. Elizabeth Laposata, a respected former medical examiner, reinforced that O’Keefe’s wounds — including facial abrasions and marks that may resemble bites — pointed to an assault, not a crash.

Karen at Trial.

The trial has also uncovered serious questions about investigative conduct. Lead State Trooper Michael Proctor, removed from the case after the discovery of biased text messages, is accused by the defense of mishandling evidence and steering the case away from potential alternate suspects inside the home where O’Keefe was last seen alive. Evidence of tampering, including holes found in O’Keefe’s sweatshirt during state testing, sparked a failed mistrial request but further fueled doubts about the investigation’s credibility.

Read, 45, once again chose not to testify, but maintained her innocence outside the courtroom. “The jury heard a lot of me already,” she said, referring to statements and recordings used by her defense.

Public support for Read has only grown since the first trial ended in a hung jury last year. Large crowds have gathered daily in Dedham, holding signs that read “Free Karen” and “Justice for John Means Truth.” Online forums and advocacy groups argue she is being scapegoated to shield others tied to law enforcement.

Closing arguments are expected Friday, with jury deliberations to follow immediately. If jurors believe what many in the public now do — that Karen Read was framed — the outcome could upend more than just a verdict. It could expose systemic failures that extend far beyond a single tragic night in Canton.